Craig opens today's show saying how all of the expectations of John Harbaugh may not be as much of a lock as people think. Plus some breaking news, Michael McDonald is actually Anita Baker. Plus, the Yankees let Edward Cabrera slip away and Mark Schlereth calls in to confirm Sean Payton is not a fan of Craig Carton! Also... it's the debut of What The F*** Wednesday!
Craig Carton rains on the Giants parade by breaking down why celebrating John Harbaugh as the next Giants head coach may be premature. In a long-form, heated debate with Chris McMonigle, Carton explains the NFL’s coaching chessboard, why Harbaugh has leverage over the Giants, and how jobs in Buffalo, Philadelphia, Green Bay, or elsewhere could change everything. A must-listen for Giants fans riding the emotional rollercoaster of the coaching search.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bounce all over the map in classic Carton Show fashion. The guys react to the latest Lenny Dykstra arrest update, then dive headfirst into the Giants’ coaching search—questioning why fans drool over John Harbaugh but shrug at Mike McCarthy despite nearly identical résumés. Along the way, Carton delivers scorching takes on fat-shaming coaches, overrated Italian food orders, vodka sauce crimes, and even revives his wild Anita Baker–Michael McDonald conspiracy. Sports, pop culture, and pure chaos wrapped into one unforgettable segment.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into the New York Giants’ chaotic coaching search. The guys debate the Rooney Rule, whether the Giants botched their timing, and why waiting on John Harbaugh could be a massive gamble. From Mike McCarthy skepticism to the nightmare scenario of Harbaugh landing with the Eagles, this segment hits everything Giants fans are arguing about right now — with Carton pulling no punches and C-Mac keeping it real.
In the final hour of today's show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the high-stakes coaching search for the New York Giants. Craig argues that the Giants need to "play chess, not checkers" by satisfying the Rooney Rule immediately to finalize a massive five-year deal with John Harbaugh before the NFL landscape shifts on Monday. They debate the risk of losing Harbaugh to potential openings in Philadelphia or Buffalo if the team waste time. The hour also features the debut of a new segment, "ETF Wednesday," where the guys discuss bizarre legal stories—including a former NFL lineman suing his ex-wife over intimate comments and Candace Owens’ legal battle with the French presidential family. Plus, a deep dive into "Shohei Ohtani Day," the slow pace of the MLB offseason, and a listener's congratulatory call to CMac on his move to the afternoon slot.
Chris McMonigle discusses the Mets boring offseason, the Giants coaching search, and more.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle debut a new recurring segment, WTF Wednesday, and it immediately spirals into classic Carton chaos. From a former NFL lineman suing his ex-wife over “compliments,” to defamation lawsuits that defy logic, the guys react to the wildest story on the internet. The conversation then pivots into a deep dive on MLB’s broken offseason, why free-agent deadlines make sense, Dodgers dominance, Yankees frustration, and Major League Baseball celebrating Shohei Ohtani — plus Carton’s lingering skepticism about the interpreter scandal. A segment that’s equal parts absurd, hilarious, and sports-radio therapy.
Former NFL Star and friend of the show Mark Schlereth calls into the Carton show to talk NFL Coaching Carousel and much more!
Only on the Carton Show: Craig Carton unveils a completely unhinged (and hilarious) music conspiracy theory claiming Anita Baker isn’t real—and is actually Michael McDonald in disguise. From slowed-down vocals to Nutty Professor comparisons, Carton and Chris McMonigle spiral into a classic pop culture rabbit hole before pivoting into Mets frustration, MLB offseason boredom, and why baseball can’t match the NFL’s buzz. Peak Carton chaos with laughs, outrage, and zero proof.
What starts as Giants coaching talk quickly turns into an all-time Carton Show detour when Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into Italian food debates. From ripping vodka sauce and Alfredo as “American crimes,” to overrated red sauce restaurants, garlic-and-oil supremacy, and what you should never order at a legit Italian spot—this segment is classic Carton chaos with callers chiming in and tempers flaring over pasta.
Craig Carton plays the role of the “Grinch” as he pumps the brakes on Giants fans celebrating the idea of John Harbaugh coming to New York. In a fiery chess-vs-checkers debate with Chris McMonigle, Carton explains why Harbaugh holds all the leverage, why the Giants can’t rush this process, and how other NFL jobs (Bills, Eagles, Packers) could derail Big Blue’s plans. Is this the greatest coaching carousel ever—or a potential disaster waiting to happen for the Giants?
The show started with Craig and C-Mac agreeing that Aaron Glenn has missed the mark again meeting with the media, but the bigger question, why does Stevie Wonder wear a watch? News broke twice on the show. The first report, Kevin Stefanski was on a plane to Newark to interview with the New York Giants. The second report, John Harbaugh was let go by the Baltimore Ravens. Should the Giants send Stefanski packing before he gets off the plane?
Craig Carton is officially back—and he wastes no time unloading on the New York Jets. In Hour 1, Craig and Chris McMonigle react to the Jets’ end-of-season press conference, ripping Aaron Glenn for a tone-deaf, arrogant message that left fans more frustrated than hopeful. Why Carton says the Jets are “not allowed to have good things,” why trust in the organization is completely broken, and why this was a massive missed opportunity to show humility.
Hour 2 of The Carton Show turns into must-listen radio when Craig Carton drops breaking news that sends Giants fans into a frenzy: Kevin Stefanski is on a plane to Newark—and then officially lands. Craig and Chris McMonigle debate whether Stefanski is the guy for Big Blue, why the Giants job might be the most attractive opening in the NFL, and whether the team should make a “hotel offer” and not let him leave the building.
dive deep into the chaotic fallout of the New York Giants' coaching changes. With Brian Daboll out, the guys debate if hiring Kevin Stefanski is a masterstroke or a massive mistake, and why Kliff Kingsbury might actually be the move that makes the fans "moist." Then, the conversation shifts to the gridiron legends and the "watered down" state of the NFL Hall of Fame. Craig makes a controversial stand against Eli Manning’s induction, sparking a heated debate about whether two Super Bowl rings are enough to mask a .500 career record.
Craig and C-Mac start the hour speaking to John Fanta about a controversial call in last night's Rutgers hoops game but then News Breaks that John Harbaugh is out as Ravens Head Coach. All hell breaks loose
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle react to the news that the Ravens have fired John Harbaugh. Safe to say Chris McMonigle is very happy.
Craig Carton & Chris McMonigle discuss the news that Kevin Stefanksi is currently enroute to Newark Airport and if he is the right man for the Giants Head Coaching vacancy
The guys debate Breece Hall’s future, whether the Jets missed their chance to trade him, and why he may have no reason to return to a losing organization. Plus, a brutal breakdown of Garrett Wilson’s shocking stat line, ownership accountability (or lack thereof), and why Woody Johnson would never face the fans the way James Dolan just did. Also Madden Ratings, 100-Fry Oil, and are pig spankings coming back?
Craig hits C-Mac with some NFL trivia and the duo tries to figure out the best way to approach the Jets coaching search
On show number two of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive into the "stark realization" of being a Jets fan: they simply aren't allowed to have good things. The duo holds nothing back while dissecting the end-of-year press conference featuring General Manager Darren Mougey and Head Coach Aaron Glenn
WFAN presents a selection of conversations about the Jets and their season-ending blowout loss at the hands of the Buffalo Bills from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show with Chris McMonigle.
We share the best reactions to the Giants' 34-17 win over the Cowboys and the decision to retain Joe Schoen from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Craig Carton Show
Craig Carton has returned to WFAN and with him, he brings in his new co-host Chris McMonigle as they talk about the end of the 2025 season with the New York Giants and Jets. First up, Giants confirm that Joe Schoen is returning, so who do we think the next head coach will be? Plus, Aaron Glenn was part of the worst season ever in New York Jets history, so let's keep him! Plus, Governor Chris Christie calls in to welcome in the boys AND James Dolan sits down with Craig and Chris to discuss why the Knicks couldn't win with Tom Thibodeau.
In this high-energy segment of The Carton Show, Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle break down the current state of New York sports following an insightful interview with James Dolan. The duo dives deep into the championship expectations for the New York Knicks and Rangers, debating whether anything short of a Finals appearance is a failure for the city's most iconic franchises.
New York Knicks and Rangers owner James Dolan joins The Carton Show with Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle for a rare, wide-ranging, and candid interview—his first public sit-down in years. Dolan opens up about the controversial decision to move on from Tom Thibodeau, why collaboration and player development drove the coaching change, and why this Knicks roster is built to win an NBA championship now, not just compete. On the Rangers side, Dolan explains his patience with Chris Drury and Mike Sullivan, the culture reset in progress, and why fans shouldn’t give up despite early struggles.
The Carton Show officially begins on WFAN as Craig Carton makes his long-awaited return to afternoon drive alongside Chris McMonigle. The debut show open gets off to a chaotic, hilarious start as Carton and C-Mac joke about the rocky launch, producer mishaps, and the pressure of Day 1. From there, they dive straight into Jets vs. Giants dysfunction, coaching decisions, quarterback futures, and Craig’s bold vision for fixing New York football. A must-listen opening that sets the tone for a brand-new era on WFAN.
Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive head-first into one of the most divisive Giants debates in years: is winning late in a lost season actually the worst result? A passionate Giants fan sparks a heated argument over draft position, instant gratification, and whether the franchise sabotaged its own future by beating the Cowboys. Craig unloads on why meaningless wins are a slap in the face to long-suffering fans, why trusting Joe Schoen on draft day is still a massive leap of faith, and how Hard Knocks permanently damaged his confidence in the Giants’ decision-makers. The discussion spirals into draft logic wars, quarterback development, tanking vs. culture, and why picking “lower” doesn’t magically make a bad GM smarter. Plus, Carton takes aim at coaching candidates, rips the idea of settling for recycled coordinators, and closes with a classic Carton rant about Madison Square Garden, Brooklyn, and celebrity bandwagon fans.
Tom Brady’s dating life from a father’s perspective, sparking a hilarious and brutally honest discussion about age gaps, parenting, and why some things just feel wrong. The show then pivots to serious New York football talk, breaking down why Joe Schoen is staying put with the Giants, how John Mara’s health factors into organizational continuity, and whether the Giants’ roster is actually closer to contention than fans want to admit. Plus, passionate calls on coaching candidates like Jon Gruden, Mike Tomlin, and Jim Harbaugh, a deep dive into why offensive line dominance is the real key to winning in the NFL, and one of the most memorable moments in WFAN history—Chris McMonigle officially “making it” with Dunkin’ Donuts after receiving donuts with his face on them. Sports, comedy, hot takes, food talk, and Carton storytelling all collide in a wildly entertaining second hour.
James Dolan joins the program and breaks his media silence as C-Mac, Craig, and Dolan get into it over a host of topics.
