Is Anita Baker Really Michael McDonald?! Carton’s Wild Music Conspiracy Goes Off the Rails

Only on the Carton Show: Craig Carton unveils a completely unhinged (and hilarious) music conspiracy theory claiming Anita Baker isn’t real—and is actually Michael McDonald in disguise. From slowed-down vocals to Nutty Professor comparisons, Carton and Chris McMonigle spiral into a classic pop culture rabbit hole before pivoting into Mets frustration, MLB offseason boredom, and why baseball can’t match the NFL’s buzz. Peak Carton chaos with laughs, outrage, and zero proof.