Hour 2: From Lenny Dykstra to Mike McCarthy: Carton Says Giants Fans Are Playing Favorites

Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle bounce all over the map in classic Carton Show fashion. The guys react to the latest Lenny Dykstra arrest update, then dive headfirst into the Giants’ coaching search—questioning why fans drool over John Harbaugh but shrug at Mike McCarthy despite nearly identical résumés. Along the way, Carton delivers scorching takes on fat-shaming coaches, overrated Italian food orders, vodka sauce crimes, and even revives his wild Anita Baker–Michael McDonald conspiracy. Sports, pop culture, and pure chaos wrapped into one unforgettable segment.