Italian Food Takes Over the Carton Show: Alfredo Sauce Wars & Overrated Red Sauce Rants

What starts as Giants coaching talk quickly turns into an all-time Carton Show detour when Craig Carton and Chris McMonigle dive headfirst into Italian food debates. From ripping vodka sauce and Alfredo as “American crimes,” to overrated red sauce restaurants, garlic-and-oil supremacy, and what you should never order at a legit Italian spot—this segment is classic Carton chaos with callers chiming in and tempers flaring over pasta.